Cal Clark vs MyFitnessPal
MyFitnessPal is a calorie counter with a food database of more than 20.5 million foods and a free food diary. Cal Clark shares the basics: food search, saved meals, calories and macros. It adds photo logging, barcode scan and no ads, all in one plan.
Feature comparison
MyFitnessPal has a 4.7-star average from 2.4 million ratings on the US App Store. Both apps count calories and macros, search foods and keep the meals you eat often. The big difference is what costs extra. Here is how the two compare across 18 features.
| Feature | Cal Clark | MyFitnessPal |
|---|---|---|
| Meal photo loggingSnap the plate, get the calories | Yes | Premium only |
| Add a note to a photo scanOil or sauce the photo can't show, for accurate calories | Yes | Not stated |
| Describe a meal in a sentenceType "2 eggs and toast", get the calories | Yes | Not stated |
| Describe a meal by voiceSay what you ate, get the calories | Yes | Premium only |
| Barcode scanScan a packaged food | Yes | Premium only |
| Food searchFind a food, pick the portion | Yes | Yes |
| Change the amount of each foodEdit the grams of every food in a meal | Yes | Yes |
| Saved meals and recipesLog a favorite meal again | Yes | Yes |
| Macro trackingProtein, carbs and fat | Yes | Yes |
| Weekly calorie budgetOne budget for the whole week | Yes | Not stated |
| Logging streakDays in a row with food logged | Yes | Yes |
| Water trackingA daily water total | Yes | Yes |
| Health app syncApple Health or Health Connect | No | Yes |
| Fasting trackerTimer for intermittent fasting | No | Premium only |
| Meal plansReady-made menus | No | Premium only |
| Free plan with no time limitFree, not a trial that ends | No | Yes |
| No adsOn the plan you use | Yes | Premium only |
| Web versionLog from a computer browser | No | Yes |
Pricing comparison
Cal Clark
Free trial3 days
- The full app
Monthly$7.99/mo
- Photo, describe, barcode and search
- Saved meals and weekly budget
- No ads
Yearly$26.99/yr
- Same as monthly
MyFitnessPal
Free$0
- Food diary and search
- Ads
Premium monthly$19.99/mo
- Barcode Scan, Meal Scan, Voice Log
- Custom macro goals
- Ad-free logging
Premium yearly$79.99/yr
- Same as monthly
One plan instead of a free app with paid parts
MyFitnessPal is free to download and free to use as a food diary with search. The ways to log faster, Barcode Scan, Meal Scan and Voice Log, are Premium features, and so are custom macro goals and ad-free logging. Premium costs $19.99 a month or $79.99 a year on the US App Store.
Cal Clark works the other way round. There is no free plan: you get 3 days with the full app, then one plan, paid monthly or yearly. Every way to log a meal is in that plan, so you never meet a feature you cannot use.
Logging a meal: a photo and a note, or a search
In MyFitnessPal, the free way to log is to search the database and pick an entry and a portion. With Premium you can also scan a barcode, scan a meal or log by voice.
In Cal Clark, the usual way is a photo. Snap the plate, then add what the photo can't see: the oil, the sauce, the dip. Cal Clark reads your note and the photo together, so the calories include what the camera missed. No photo? Describe the meal in your own words, scan a barcode or search for a food.
A diary without ads
MyFitnessPal shows ads in the free app. Ad-free logging is listed as a Premium feature, and recent App Store reviews say the ads now cover part of the diary.
Cal Clark has no ads in any plan. The space under your meals shows what you have eaten today and what is left, with calories and macros side by side.
Where MyFitnessPal is the better choice
MyFitnessPal has a free plan with no time limit, and you can log from a web browser as well as the app. It has been around for many years, and its food database is very large.
If you want a free diary and do not mind searching for each food, MyFitnessPal does that well. If you want photo logging, barcode scan and no ads without choosing which of them to pay for, Cal Clark fits better.
What MyFitnessPal users complain about
Real App Store reviews of MyFitnessPal, and what Cal Clark does about each problem.
Basic features behind the paywall
“Locking previously basic features like barcode scanning behind a paywall is asinine.”
Cal Clark approach
Cal Clark has one plan. Photo, describe, barcode and search are all in it, and the 3-day free trial includes the full app.
Ads on the logging screen
“There’s nothing wrong with having ads but do they really need to be the biggest part of my screen?”
Cal Clark approach
Cal Clark shows no ads, on any screen.
Updates that add taps
“I absolutely loathe the latest update and the one before that added clicks to get anything done.”
Cal Clark approach
Cal Clark keeps the app simple. We count the taps each step needs, because one extra tap at every meal adds up every day. Logging a meal is: snap the plate, add a short note for what the photo cannot show, like the oil or the sauce, so the calories are more accurate, and you are done.
Too much app for a food log
“Latest updates ruined the app, over complicated and made it less user friendly.”
Cal Clark approach
Cal Clark does one job: log what you eat and show what is left for today and this week, with calories and macros side by side.
Numbers you cannot trust
“Most data is wrong, they charge for barcode scan and it usually doesn’t work.”
Cal Clark approach
Cal Clark takes its food values from official sources. Fresh foods like chicken, rice or apples use the nutrition tables that government institutions publish, such as the US Department of Agriculture and Germany's Max Rubner Institute.
For photos, Cal Clark adds one step: a short note. A photo cannot show the oil in the pan or the sauce under the rice, so you write it down and the estimate includes it. This matters because no app can read exact calories from a picture. A review of 52 studies found photo estimates off by up to 38% on average.
Barcode scan is in the plan, not an extra. If a product is not found, take a photo of its nutrition label and Cal Clark fills in the numbers.
Bottom line
Pick MyFitnessPal if you want a free food diary with no time limit, a web version, or the biggest food database to search. Pick Cal Clark if you want photo, typed, spoken and barcode logging in one plan, with no ads and a weekly budget next to the daily one. It costs $26.99 a year, about a third of the $79.99 a year for MyFitnessPal Premium.
References
- MyFitnessPal on the US App Store: rating, prices and reviews
- MyFitnessPal Premium: what each plan includes
- Shonkoff et al. (2023), AI-based digital image dietary assessment methods compared to humans and ground truth: a systematic review. Annals of Medicine
- MyFitnessPal food diary on the web (opens the sign-in page)
Read the full MyFitnessPal review
Frequently asked questions
Is MyFitnessPal free?
MyFitnessPal has a free plan with a food diary, search and ads. Barcode Scan, Meal Scan, Voice Log, custom macro goals and ad-free logging need Premium: $19.99 a month or $79.99 a year on the US App Store.
What is the main difference between Cal Clark and MyFitnessPal?
MyFitnessPal is a free food diary with paid extras. Cal Clark has one plan with every way to log a meal (photo, description, barcode and search) and no ads.
Which is cheaper, Cal Clark or MyFitnessPal?
The MyFitnessPal free plan costs nothing, but it has ads and no barcode or meal scan. With those features, MyFitnessPal Premium is $79.99 a year. Cal Clark is $26.99 a year or $7.99 a month, after a 3-day free trial.
Log your meals with a photo.
Cal Clark shows calories and macros in seconds. Join the waitlist and we'll tell you when the app goes live.
3-day free trial. No ads.
More comparisons
Cal Clark vs Cal AIPhoto firstPhoto-first calorie tracker with Groups for friends. Scan results need a subscription after a 3-day trial.
Cal Clark vs LifesumLife ScoreFood tracker with recipes, meal plans and a Life Score. Photo, text and voice logging need Premium.
Cal Clark vs Lose It!Free calorie budgetFree calorie budget and diary with ads. Photo, voice, barcode and macro tracking need Premium at $79.99 a year.
Cal Clark vs MyNetDiaryAd-freeAd-free diary with free barcode scan, macros and water. Meal Scan from a photo needs Premium.
Cal Clark vs YazioNo signup neededFree calorie counter with ads, barcode scan and a streak. Photo, text and voice logging need Pro.
Cal Clark vs Cronometer95+ nutrientsFree diary with 95+ nutrients and free barcode scan. Photo and voice logging and no ads need Gold.