Cal Clark
VS

Cal Clark vs MacroFactor

MacroFactor is a macro tracker with a 4.8-star US App Store average, and its targets adapt each week to your weight trend. Cal Clark shares a lot: photo logging with text, describe, barcode scan, a weekly calorie budget and no ads, in a paid app with a free trial. It costs less, and the app is in English, Polish, German and Spanish.

Feature comparison

MacroFactor has a 4.8-star average from 23,723 ratings on the US App Store. Both apps are paid, ad-free, and log meals from a photo with text, a description, a barcode or a search. The big difference is the price and how the targets are set. Here is how the two compare across 18 features.

FeatureCal ClarkMacroFactor
Meal photo loggingSnap the plate, get the caloriesYesYes
Add a note to a photo scanOil or sauce the photo can't show, for accurate caloriesYesYes
Describe a meal in a sentenceType "2 eggs and toast", get the caloriesYesYes
Describe a meal by voiceSay what you ate, get the caloriesYesYes
Barcode scanScan a packaged foodYesYes
Food searchFind a food, pick the portionYesYes
Change the amount of each foodEdit the grams of every food in a mealYesYes
Saved meals and recipesLog a favorite meal againYesYes
Macro trackingProtein, carbs and fatYesYes
Weekly calorie budgetOne budget for the whole weekYesYes
Logging streakDays in a row with food loggedYesNot stated
Water trackingA daily water totalYesYes
Health app syncApple Health or Health ConnectNoYes
Fasting trackerTimer for intermittent fastingNoNot stated
Meal plansReady-made menusNoNot stated
Free plan with no time limitFree, not a trial that endsNoNo
No adsOn the plan you useYesYes
Web versionLog from a computer browserNoNot stated

Pricing comparison

Cal Clark

  • Free trial3 days

    • The full app
  • Monthly$7.99/mo

    • Photo, describe, barcode and search
    • Saved meals and weekly budget
    • No ads
  • Yearly$26.99/yr

    • Same as monthly

MacroFactor

  • Free trial7 days

    • The full app
  • Monthly$11.99/mo

    • Food logging, coaching and weekly check-ins
    • No ads
  • Half year$47.99

    • Same as monthly
  • Yearly$71.99/yr

    • Same as monthly

Two paid apps, two prices

MacroFactor and Cal Clark both skip the free plan and the ads. You try the full app, then pay monthly or yearly.

MacroFactor costs $11.99 a month, $47.99 for half a year or $71.99 a year on the US App Store, after a 7-day free trial. Cal Clark costs $7.99 a month or $26.99 a year, after a 3-day free trial.

Targets that adapt, or targets for your goal

MacroFactor estimates how much energy you burn from your food log and your weight trend. Each week it checks in and can change your calorie and macro targets.

Cal Clark sets calorie and macro targets for the goal you pick: lose weight, gain mass, fuel training or stay healthy. You can change the goal any time. It shows what you ate today and what is left, and a weekly budget next to the daily one.

Logging a meal with a photo and a note

Both apps let you add words to a meal photo. MacroFactor calls it Photo & Text: take a photo and add a description to improve the analysis.

In Cal Clark, after the photo the app asks what the photo can't show: the oil, the sauce, the dip. Cal Clark reads your note and the photo together, so the calories include what the camera missed. No photo? Describe the meal, scan a barcode or search for a food.

Your language

MacroFactor's App Store page lists English and Japanese. Cal Clark is in English, Polish, German and Spanish.

Where MacroFactor is the better choice

MacroFactor goes deeper on coaching. Its expenditure estimate and weekly check-ins suit people who want their targets tuned to their real weight change, for a cut or a bulk. It also tracks micronutrients, habits and periods, and it gives you a longer free trial.

If you want that coaching, MacroFactor is a strong pick. If you want the same ways to log for less money, or the app in Polish, German or Spanish, Cal Clark fits better.

What MacroFactor users complain about

Real App Store reviews of MacroFactor, and what Cal Clark does about each problem.

Numbers you cannot trust

“Overpriced subscription, terrible database”App Store
“106g of protein logged when the shake said 30g”

Cal Clark approach

Cal Clark takes its food values from official sources. Fresh foods like chicken, rice or apples use the nutrition tables that government institutions publish, such as the US Department of Agriculture and Germany's Max Rubner Institute.

For photos, Cal Clark adds one step: a short note. A photo cannot show the oil in the pan or the sauce under the rice, so you write it down and the estimate includes it. This matters because no app can read exact calories from a picture. A review of 52 studies found photo estimates off by up to 38% on average.

If a barcode is not found, take a photo of the nutrition label and Cal Clark fills in the numbers.

Hard to log a meal

“Incredibly overcomplicated, not user intuitive”App Store
“It was so difficult to log food and is not user intuitive at all.”

Cal Clark approach

Cal Clark keeps the app simple. We count the taps each step needs, because one extra tap at every meal adds up every day. Logging a meal is: snap the plate, add a short note for what the photo cannot show, like the oil or the sauce, so the calories are more accurate, and you are done.

A price that came as a surprise

“71 dollars”App Store
“My son bought this app not knowing it was $71.”

Cal Clark approach

Cal Clark is paid through the App Store or Google Play, monthly or yearly. You see the price before the trial starts, and you cancel in your phone's subscription settings, like any other app.

Bottom line

Pick MacroFactor if you want targets that adjust each week to your weight trend and an estimate of how much energy you burn. Pick Cal Clark if you want photo, typed, spoken and barcode logging, a note on each photo for the oil or sauce the camera cannot see, for more accurate calories, a weekly budget and no ads, in English, Polish, German or Spanish. It costs $26.99 a year, against $71.99 a year for MacroFactor.

References

Read the full MacroFactor review

Frequently asked questions

Is MacroFactor free?

No. MacroFactor has a 7-day free trial and no free plan. After that it costs $11.99 a month, $47.99 for half a year or $71.99 a year on the US App Store.

What is the main difference between Cal Clark and MacroFactor?

Both are paid, ad-free apps that log meals by photo with text, description, barcode and search, with a weekly budget. MacroFactor changes your targets each week from your weight trend. Cal Clark sets targets for the goal you pick and costs less.

Which is cheaper, Cal Clark or MacroFactor?

Cal Clark: $7.99 a month or $26.99 a year, after a 3-day free trial. MacroFactor: $11.99 a month or $71.99 a year, after a 7-day free trial.

Log your meals with a photo.

Cal Clark shows calories and macros in seconds. Join the waitlist and we'll tell you when the app goes live.

3-day free trial. No ads.

More comparisons